World · Total Chess Budapest
Carlsen Skips Five Games at Total Chess Budapest, Then Finishes 17th
Magnus Carlsen forfeited two games after his result was already safe and three while his match was still open. The arbiters scored every forfeit the same way, and several players and FIDE officials criticized the choice.
Magnus Carlsen, the world No. 1 on FIDE's November 2026 classical list (rated 2823), forfeited five games at the Total Chess pilot event in Budapest. Two came after he had already secured the result he needed. Three came while his match was still undecided.
The arbiters handled each one the same way. In a statement on November 20, chief arbiter Anastasia Sorokina said the opponent had to be at the board for every scheduled game, White's clock was started on time under the FIDE Laws of Chess, and a player who did not arrive within the allowed time lost by forfeit.
How the scoring works
Knockout matches in Budapest lasted two days. Each day had four blitz games, two rapid games and one Fast Classic game (45 minutes plus 30 seconds a move). A win was worth 1 point in blitz, 4 in rapid and 8 in Fast Classic, with half for a draw. Scores reset each night. Winning both days, or winning one day and tying the other, won the match. One day each meant an Armageddon game.
Because the last game of the day is worth 8 of its 20 points, a player can lock up a day before the Fast Classic game begins, or fall well behind and still win the day with that one game.
Twice against Assaubayeva, with the result already safe
Carlsen finished fifth in his group, with nine draws and one loss in ten Fast Classic games, and moved to the bracket for places 17 to 20. His first opponent there was Bibisara Assaubayeva.
On Tuesday, November 17, he scored 3.5 out of 4 in blitz and won both rapid games for an 11.5–0.5 lead. Even a Fast Classic win would have brought Assaubayeva only to 8.5, so the day was his. Carlsen did not come to the board, and the forfeit made the final score 11.5–8.5.
On Wednesday, November 18, he won all four blitz games and scored a win and a draw in rapid to lead 10–2. A forfeit would leave the day tied 10–10, and after his Tuesday win a tie was enough to take the match. He forfeited again.
According to ChessBase, Carlsen told Norway's TV 2 after the first forfeit that the match was already decided, and that in his view a game played after that point should not count toward ratings. ChessBase also reported that organizers had told players at the pre-event technical meeting that all games would be played and rated; Fast Classic games count toward FIDE classical ratings. Total Chess founder Kjell Madland said that with the result decided, Carlsen did not need to play, and that the regulations had not been changed (ChessBase).
Against Artemiev, with the match still open
The match for 17th place was against Vladislav Artemiev.
On Thursday, November 19, Carlsen lost the first blitz game and won the next three for a 3–1 lead. He then skipped both rapid games. The two forfeits gave Artemiev 8 points and a 9–3 lead, so Carlsen needed to win the Fast Classic game to take the day.
Before the rapid games, Carlsen told TV 2: "I'm not coming back until the fast classic." He said he "would rather be more rested for the classical," according to reports by ChessBase and the Press Trust of India.
He then won the Fast Classic game with White, his first win at that time control in Budapest, and took the day 11–9.
On Friday, November 20, Carlsen won the blitz 2.5–1.5, and Artemiev scored a win and a draw in the rapid games to lead 7.5–4.5. Carlsen then forfeited the Fast Classic game. That gave Artemiev the day 15.5–4.5 and sent the match to Armageddon, which Carlsen won with Black. He finished 17th and Artemiev 18th. The reports we were able to read did not give Carlsen's reason for Friday's forfeit (checked November 20).
Reaction
The forfeits in the middle of an open match drew the most criticism. Fabiano Caruana told ChessBase India that leaving in the middle of a match was worse than the earlier forfeits, and that a player who skips a game should lose the whole match. Ian Nepomniachtchi said the player should be expelled from the tournament, and Hans Niemann criticized the rapid forfeits on social media (World Chess). Earlier in the week, FIDE's Emil Sutovsky had called the first forfeit unsportsmanlike, and Hikaru Nakamura said objections to a tournament's rules should be raised before the event, not during it (ChessBase). FIDE Deputy President Viswanathan Anand said he would not have skipped games himself and that the rule will need to be tightened (World Chess; Press Trust of India).
Not every reaction was critical. Wesley So took a more understanding view of the Assaubayeva forfeits, pointing to what a draw could have cost Carlsen in rating points (ChessBase).
Carlsen was not the only player to skip games. Richard Rapport did not play his Fast Classic games on November 18, when his match was already lost, or on November 19, when he had already won the day. A third player skipped a Fast Classic game on November 18 after winning his day (ChessBase; Total Chess). The organizers' statement said that some players missed games after their results were settled, and that on November 19 one player missed both rapid games while his match was still open; the game reports show that player was Carlsen.
What Carlsen has said about classical chess
In a November 2024 interview with The Straits Times, published December 1, 2024, Carlsen said he still enjoyed sitting at the board for hours, but not the work that comes before long games. "The problem is, everything that has to do with the preparation for long games, I'm quite done with," he said. He added that opening positions had been studied so deeply, partly with computers, that finding something new had become a struggle.
That interview is background. It does not show why he skipped any particular game in Budapest. The reasons he gave there, as reported, were that the result was already decided (November 17) and that he wanted to be rested for the Fast Classic game (November 19).
What happens next
Total Chess has said the Budapest pilot was a test of the format. It plans to gather feedback from players, arbiters and others before the first full season begins in March 2027, and says it has no set view that the rules need to change. The chief arbiter's daily reports will be sent to FIDE now that the event is over.
Sources
- Total Chess, "Giri and Firouzja Take First-Day Leads in Total Chess Semifinals": November 17, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "Anish Giri and Alireza Firouzja Reach Total Chess Final": November 18, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "Giri Takes the Lead in Total Chess Final": November 19, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "Firouzja Wins Total Chess Budapest Pilot": November 20, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "Statement on player non-attendance at the Total Chess Pilot": November 20, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "Firouzja, Caruana, Giri and Vachier-Lagrave Win Groups in Budapest": November 16, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- Total Chess, "How to Become a Winner in Budapest? The Format Explained": October 23, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- ChessBase, "Total Chess: Firouzja and Giri win opening sets, Carlsen sparks controversy" (checked November 20, 2026)
- ChessBase, "Total Chess: Giri and Firouzja to battle for tournament title" (checked November 20, 2026)
- ChessBase, "Total Chess: Giri takes early lead over Firouzja, Carlsen forfeits rapid games": November 20, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- World Chess, "Giri Closes In On First World Title (Well, Kinda) As Carlsen's Total Chess Forfeits Continue" (checked November 20, 2026)
- Press Trust of India, via ThePrint, "Carlsen forfeits rapid games, opts to play Fast Classic": November 19, 2026 (checked November 20, 2026)
- The Straits Times, "Chess is a really harsh game. When you lose, your ego is deflated, says world No. 1 Magnus Carlsen": published December 1, 2024 (checked November 20, 2026)
- FIDE, Top 100 Players, November 2026: read by hand, one page, nothing stored (checked November 20, 2026)
Spotted an error? Write to corrections@headlinechess.com. Our corrections policy.